Shorea robusta or Sal is one of the important timber species of India. Sal forest ecosystems, which are found in MP, UP, Himachal Pradesh, Orissa , Bihar and other states of India are under threat from a pest beetle called the Sal Borer. Although the history of the Sal Borer attack in sal forests is not new and dates back to 1899, there has been wide spread destruction and felling of infected Sal trees in the last 2 years in various parts of India. The problem is serious enough for the Ministry of Environment and Forests to constitute a task force to monitor the problem.
Over the last two years, hundreds of infected trees have been felled which has led to significant concern amongst foresters, environmental activists and people. Remedial measures to control the beetle have not been different from what was being done in the early part of this century to control epidemics. These methods largely rely on physical destruction of the borer beetle. There are no effective chemical or biological control mechanisms in use.
This page provides detailed information about this problem, the beetle and its life history, history of incidents of infection and other issues related to this problem which threaten the Sal forests of India.
Suggestions from forest entomologists to solve this problem are welcome. You can write to Dr. C.S. Rathore.
Page Posted on 30th April 2000
SAL FORESTS
Shorea robusta
, commonly known in India as Sal is one of the important commercial timber species of India. Sal is widely distributed in central and Northern India. The tree yields timber, which is used largely for construction works, railway sleepers and in mining operations. The timber is also used for beam, columns, bridges, piles, roofing door, and window frames, rafters, decking railing etc. , agricultural implements (plough, yokes, harrows), boat building (dug outs), carts, marine piles, motor lorry and bus bodies. Lops and tops of Sal are very good fuel wood.The caloric value of completely dried heartwood is 5433 calories. Sal tree also exudes an oleoresin, or ral that is valued as incense in religious ceremonies. It is also used in paint and Varnishes. The presence of resin in the heartwood is responsible for higher calorific value. The Sal seed contains 12-19 percent fat. The fat is used for soap manufacture. After removal of certain ingredients, it is also used as substitute for borea fallow and cocoa butter in the manufacture of chocolates and confectionery.Sal forests constitute an important ecosystem, which provides a cool and calm environment to many regions of India also being rich in bio diversity. Thus Sal is thus important both ecologically and economically. Sal forests in India occupies 105790 sq. Km area in two distinct regions, Northern and central region separated by gangetic plains. As regards the area under Sal forests, Orissa leads among the different states with about 38,300-sq.km area under Sal forest followed respectively by Madhya Pradesh 27,800 sq.km, Bihar 21,410 Uttar Pradesh 5,710, West Bengal 5,700, Assam 6500, Himachal Pradesh -330 and Haryana with 40 sq.km.
Though Sal and Teak constitute two distinct vegetation zones, both vegetation types
also occur together in Madhya Pradesh constituting the rare ecosystem. Madhya Pradesh is
the state with second largest area under Sal forests, distributed mainly in eastern part
of the state forming 25 percent of the total Sal forest of the country.
District wise distribution of Sal forest in M.P.
| District | Area Sq. Km. |
| Baastar | 3,175.40 |
| Raipur | 1861.00 |
| Bilashpur | 3778.33 |
| Raighar | 1,692.96 |
| Surguja | 6,467 |
| Sidhi | 1825.81 |
| Shahdol | 2,030 |
| Mandla | 2920 |
| Durg | 1,633 |
| Rajnandgaon | 190 |
| Balaghat | 134.77 |
| Chhindwara | 152.53 |
| Hoshangabad | 70.65 |
| Jabalpur | 108 |
| Rewa | 2 |
This tree species belonging to family Depterocarpaceae is at the moment in the news for the massive attack by a woodborer insect in the central and eastern part of Madhya Pradesh and also Orissa. MP forest department has felled nearly 6 lakhs trees as a remedial measures in year 1996-97.Till the end of the year 1999 almost 30 lakhs trees have been felled. The beetles feed during day light on the fresh sap from the bark and the sapwood of the Sal trees. This sap can attract insects from a distance of 400 meters.
HISTORY OF BORER ATTACK
The Sal heartwood borer , Hoplocerambyx spinicornis , is an inhabitant (or is endemic) of the whole of the Sal tract of India ( and Indian Sub-continent) , ranging from Goalpara of Assam to Bhutan, Jalpaiguri and Kurseong Forest Divisions, Rajabhatkhawa (West Bengal), Chhotanagpur, Palamau, Singhbhumi (Bihar), Balaghat, Mandla, Hoshangabad and Dindori of Madhaya Pradesh, Thano, Phandowala and Timli in Dehradun Forest Division, and Lansdowne and Kalagarh Forest Divisions of Uttar Pradesh besides Nahan Forest Division in Himachal Pradesh.
The infestation of Sal borer is considered to be epidemic when the trees affected are more than 1.0 percent of the total growing stock of the trees. Several epidemics of this pest have been reported from different Sal growing areas of India existing from Himachal Pradesh to Assam and Orissa to Madhya Pradesh. The available records show that the infestation of this borer was reported in Apalchand range of Jalpaiguri Forest Division of West Bengal, Banjar valley reserve, Motinala, Dindori, Karanjira and Khanat ranges of South Mandala Forest Division of Madhya Pradesh etc., in 1905 - 06. After this, the borer remained endemic for many years again resulting in an epidemic in Amosoi of Nowgoan forest division and Mandala and Janali Hel blocks of Goalpara divison in Assam during 1961.
Another epidemic was reported in Thano forest of Deharadun forest division in 1913. The epidemics of this borer in standing trees were however, recorded for the first time in 1916-17 in some compartments of this division. The trees of all sizes and ages were attacked in the epidemic, though, the preference was for trees of 60-120 cm. girth class. The number of sal trees attacked in 66 compartments of Thano forest were about 6772 in the year 1916-17 . This number rose to 10432 trees in December 1917 and subsequently 11440 trees during June 1919. These epidemics continued up to 1924 and spread to Kaulagarh and Lansdowne ranges of Dehradun division.
Continuous remedial methods adopted during this period brought this epidemic under control bringing the infestation below endemic levels by the year 1928. Later, the borer again multiplied to epidemic proportions slowly in Timli Range of Dehradun forest division in 1958 and continued to thrive upto 1960. The population was brought down to endemic levels after 1960 by continuously adopting the remedial methods after the epidemic was noticed.
In Lambirao compartment of Thano Range the incidence of borer attack again went above endemic level in 1964 when 8475 infested standing trees were enumerated and finally felled. This epidemic spread to 1185 acres and caused destruction of about 2213 infested Sal trees in Lambiaro Block and 166 trees in Ramnagar areas in 1965. Continuous trapping methods and felling of dead and dying trees lowered the epidemic. The infestation again increased in above blocks of Thano forest division in 1975-76 and continued up to 1976-77 but was suppressed by the use of remedial methods in time. More recently from 1994 till date (April 2000), there has been a gradual build up of the attack of sal borer in Thano range. This time, the infestation is reported in Lambirao, Ramnagar, Thano and Maidan blocks.
In Nahan forest division of Himachal Pradesh, the epidemic of the borer started from 1949 in Gorakhpur and Jamniwala sal areas. In May 1949, 211 trees were attacked. The number of trees attacked rose to 2225 trees in 1950-51. In this region during the early period of epidemic, the attack was apparently heavier on relatively smaller girths and spread more evenly to higher girths.
In Bihar the Sal heartwood borer infestation was recorded as early as in 1899 and again in 1906. The population build up was slow at that time. But during 1961 in Palamau and Singhabum districts, a large epidemic occurred covering a forest area of around 491 sq. kms. During this epidemic in the area, 60 Sal trees per hectare were found attacked by the borer.
From West Bengal, an epidemic was recorded during 1931-34 covering an area of 1850 acres and killing 3177 Sal trees in Sevok range of the Kurseong forest division. Again during 1974, an epidemic of Sal borer was recorded from Raja Bhatkhawa forest division covering an area of 1360 Ha. killing 23120 Sal trees.
In Madhya Pradesh, the first report of green Sal trees apparently dying under the attacks of an insect borer was recorded in 1905 from the Balaghat forests. Later, Sir George Hart, the then Chief Conservator of Forests, Madhya Pradesh noted the occurrence of this beetle in the Khannat forests of Mandla forest division in 1912. The borer is endemic to this area and ultimately increased to a considerable number in Banjar and Motinala ranges of Madhya Pradesh where 423 and 63 trees respectively were found to be attacked by the Sal borer. It was brought under control by felling the attacked trees. This infestation which was endemic between 1915-22 in Karanjia and Dindori was found to be suddenly reaching epidemic levels in1923-24. In the year 1924, the Chief Conservatorof Forests, the Silviculturist of Madhya Pradesh and divisional forest officer, South Mandla forest division inspected Banjar range and observed a heavy infestation of Sal borer in about 27 acres. The infestation in this range was severe in nearly half of the standing stock of Sal trees that were attacked by this borer. During the same year, the infestation was noticed in Motinala, Dindori and Karanjia ranges of South Mandla forest division. Felling of heavily attacked Sal trees was carried out from 1924 onwards. Nearly 2960 attacked trees were felled in 1924 from the above ranges, whose number raised to 28521 trees in 1925 and nearly 150000 trees in 1926-27. Of these, a few thousands were sold, nearly 40000 were debarked and stoved, and between 50000-60000 were burned to check its further spread.
The number of attacked trees also increased in other neighboring forest divisions. Baihar and Raigarh ranges of Balaghat and Lamni range of Bilaspur, Rewa state, Pendra etc were impacted. The total number of trees attacked over the whole infested Sal area before epidemic was checked, was estimated to be about 70 lakh (7 Million- 10 Lakh being 1 Million). The effect of adverse weather conditions in the replication of this borer together with remedial methods adopted resulted in marked decrease in the intensity of the borer attack in all the above ranges during the year 1927-28. Continuous use of this technique resulted in fall in the intensity of the borer attack in the year 1928-29 and finally an end of this epidemic in 1929-30.
Trap tree operations were continued in Banjar, Motinala and Didori ranges regularly with 1 or 2 interruptions in some ranges from 1931 onwards. As a result the population of borer could not increase to epidemic proportions. As soon as the population of borer was observed to increase in the year 1944-45 in Banjar range, it was immediately brought under control. The population of borer was again noticed to increase in a few compartments of Dindori forest range in 1961-62 that reached to epidemiclevels not only in Dindori but also in Bajag and Karanji forest ranges in 1962-63. Trap tree operations were carried out from June 1963 to the first week of September 1963 by using about 54208 trap trees to combat the epidemic which kept the problem under control in a few years.
The epidemic of Sal borer was again reported from Panchamarhi Hills in Hoshangabad forest division in 1976 . This epidemic considerably increased in 1978-79. Control remedies were initiated with the help of scientists of Regional Forest Research Centre of Forest research Institute, Dehradun from 1979 and were carried out continuously for 4 years. It was found that the population reached to endemic by the year 1982.
Recently , there have been reports of Sal borer infestations from the State of Orissa also.
ABOUT THE SAL BORER
About 148 insect pests attack Sal. Of these, the major devastating insect pest is Sal Heartwood borer, Hoplocerambyx spinicornis belonging to the family Cerambyedeace. This beetle, popularly known as the longicorn beetle, is a dreaded woodborer. It occurs extensively in Deharadun Sal forests, It also occurs in Haldwani, Ramnagar and Kalaghar forests of UP. It is quite abundant in Mandla, Balaghat and Bilashpur Sal forest of Madhya Pradesh. It has also been reported from Orissa , Assam, West Bengal and Nahan Sal forests of Himachal Pradesh.
The life cycle of the Sal Borer consists of: the following stages :
1. Eggs.
2. Larvae or grubs
3. Pupae
4. Beetles
The life cycle can be summarized in four stages. The adult beetle lives for 1 month outside the Sal tree. Eggs are laid inside the tree and takes 7days to hatch. The Larva remains inside the tree between 6-10 months. The pupa remains inside the tree for 1-4 months before becoming an adult. The life cycle is summarized in the figure below:

Beetle
Eggs
| Humidity % | 55 | 61 | 66 | 78 | 89 | 91 | 100 |
| No. of eggs | 0 | 42 | 83 | 273 | 416 | 465 | 40 |
The hatching takes place in 3-7 days. The viability of the eggs varies between 75-100% depending on the weather conditions. The optimum humidity required for maximum number of eggs to hatch is 90-100%.
Larvae
Picture Gallery |
Pupae
ENDEMIC ATTACK
These insects are always present in the Sal forest in low densities. This is termed as the endemic stage technically. The population of these insects sometimes explodes during favorable climatic conditions such as more humid conditions and temperature close to 27-28 degree during early monsoon. Thus although a tree may carry many eggs, only a few hatch during the unfavorable years. In contrasts, most eggs produce larvae when the climate is conductive. Apart from climate, several other factors enable the Sal borer to reach epidemic proportions. Homogenous, even aged, dense stands of Sal trees such as plantations, provides a fertile ground for the spread of the insects. Stressed trees are more susceptible to attack e.g. those experiencing nutrient deficiency or exposure to severe winds or climber load or reduced vigor due to compression or genetically lower natural resistance.
EXTENT OF INFESTATION
The affected trees have been classified into following 7 categories (Beeson-1941) which is being followed by the Forest Departments in India in marking the trees according to the extent :of damage:
Category I :
A tree is completely dead. Leafless crown; Leafless Epichormic branches; Wood dust in large heaps.Category II :
Some portion of trunk alive, Crown dead and brown; almost all the epicormic branches dead and brown; wood dust in large heaps.Category III :
Crown dead and brown; epicormics of bark dead in upper parts; alive in lower part of the trunk; wood dust in heaps upto 7-8 cm high.Category IV :
Crown damaged severely. In most of the case no crown. Wood dust in large heaps.Category V :
Crown partly green and partly brown; epicormics green; wood dust scattered.Category VI :
Crown green, one or two epicormics branches brown; Excessive resin oozing out of the tree as a part of defense mechanism; Stump with large heap of wood dust.Category VII:
Initiation of Borer attack. Crown and epicormics entirely green; resin abundant or absent; wood dust scattered or scanty.
PROBABLE CAUSES OF EPIDEMIIC
Climate:
Ecological succession:
Evolutionary Succession:
Silvicultural Genetic Erosion:
Further, increasing physical distance between the neighboring trees of the same species retards the rate at which the pest spreads. Indeed, the worst affected Sal area include its pure and dense stands while areas where its proportion is low the degree of infestation is less or negligible.
Environmental stress:
Fires:
Forest Hygiene:
CURRENT REMEDIES
Trap tree operation
Collection and Killing of insects
Some of the forest entomologist's say that the trap trees can attract up to 90% of the borer beetles in a given area. Further, they say that an infested tree may contain 300 to 600 larvae, most of which may metamorphose into beetles. By this logic, from 2 lakhs trees that were infested by 1996 monsoon, at least 6 corer insects might have emerged, besides those emerging from the trees growing on the private lands.
Cutting affected tree
The working plan prescribe cutting of all infested trees including the dead ones, except
those from category 7, i.e. those with least infection, as evident from their fully intact
green crown. In 1996-97 6 lakhs out of the 18 lakhs trees were identified and marked
as infested belong to the category 7. These were marked for observation and were decided
that those would not be felled until they pass onto other categories of infestation, by
the time of other survey. Of the remaining 14 lakhs trees , the department had cut nearly
6 lakhs trees by 15 January 1998 and by the end of 1999 about 30 lakhs trees have been
felled.
Biochemical control
ISSUES RELATED TO BORER ATTACK
Scientific issue
Socio economic issue:
Political issues
Policy Issues
[TOP]
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
The Sal Borer problem has in the recent times come up a major problem plaguing Indian Sal forests. Although attacks have been known to occur for a long time, there is still no control of this pest except for what has been mentioned in the current remedies section. As a result, there continues to be a large-scale damage to the Sal forests in various parts of India. In April 2000, there has been a massive infestation in the Sal forests of Orissa . A more effective method like some form of chemical or biological control breaking the life cycle of the pest is required to combat this very destructive pest infestation.
REFERENCES
CREDITS
Material on this page has been written by Kabita Ghimre and Amitabh Dongre, PGDFM Class of 1999-2001, IIFM Bhopal. If you wish to contribute matter on this page, please send a mail to
Dr. Chinmaya S. Rathore [TOP]
[About IIFM | Databank Main Page | FIS ]